This chapter will examine a variety of ways to architect a system with JavaServer Pages, Servlets, and JavaBeans. We will see a series of different architectures, each a development of the one before. The diagram below shows this process in outline; the individual parts of the diagram will be explained in turn later in the chapter.

System Architecture

When Sun introduced Java ServerPages, some were quick to claim that Servlets had been replaced as the preferred request handling mechanism in web-enabled enterprise architectures. Although JSP is a key component of the Java 2 Platform Enterprise Edition (J2EE) specification, serving as the preferred request handler and response mechanism, we must investigate further to understand its relationship with Servlets. For all the latest information on J2EE, including documentation relating to some of the issues discussed in this chapter, please refer to http://java.sun.com/j2ee.

Other sections of this book explain the implementation details of JSP source translation and compilation into a Servlet. Understanding that JSP is built on top of the Servlet API, and utilizes Servlet semantics, raises some interesting questions. Should we no longer develop standalone Servlets in our web-enabled systems? Is there some way to combine Servlets and JSPs? If so, where do we place our Java code? Are there any other components involved in the request processing, such as JavaBeans? If so, where do they fit into the architecture and what type of role do they fulfill?

It is important to understand that, although JSP technology will be a powerful successor to basic Servlets, they have an evolutionary relationship and can be used in a cooperative and complementary manner.

Given this premise, we will investigate how these two technologies, each a Java Standard Extension, can be used co-operatively along with other components, such as JavaBeans, to create Java-based web-enabled systems. We will examine architectural issues as they relate to JSP and Servlets and discuss some effective designs while looking at the tradeoffs of each. Before jumping directly into a discussion of specific architectures, though, we will briefly examine the need to develop a variety of architectures.

One of the main reasons why the Java Server Pages technology has evolved into what it is today (and it's still evolving) is the overwhelming technical need to simplify application design by separating dynamic content from static template display data. The foundation for JSP was laid down with the initial development of the Java Web Server from Sun, which utilized page compilation and focused on embedding HTML inside Java code. As applications came to be based more on business objects and n-tier architectures, the focus changed to separating HTML from Java code, while still maintaining the integrity and flexibility the technology provided.

In Chapter 5 we saw how beans and objects can be bound to different contexts just by defining a certain scope. Good application design builds on this idea and tries to separate the objects, the presentation and the manipulation of the objects into distinct, distinguishable layers.

Another benefit of utilizing JSP is that it allows us to more cleanly separate the roles of a web production/HTML designer individual from a software developer. Remember that a common development scenario with Servlets was to embed the HTML presentation markup within the Java code of the Servlet itself, which can be troublesome. In our discussion, we will consider the Servlet solely as a container for Java code, while our entire HTML presentation template is encapsulated within a JSP source page. The question then arises as to how much Java code should remain embedded within our JSP source pages, and if it is taken out of the JSP source page, where should it reside?

Let's investigate this further. On any web-based project, multiple roles and responsibilities will exist. For example, an individual who designs HTML pages fulfills a web production role while someone who writes software in the Java programming language fulfills a software development role.

On small-scale projects these roles might be filled by the same individual, or two individuals working closely together. On a larger project, they will likely be filled by multiple individuals, who might not have overlapping skill sets, and are less productive if made too dependent on the workflow of the other.

If code that could be factored out to a mediating Servlet is included instead within HTML markup, then the potential exists for individuals in the software development role and those in the web production role to become more dependent than necessary on the progress and workflow of the other. Such dependencies may create a more error-prone environment, where inadvertent changes to code by other team members become more common.

This gives us some insight into one reason why we continue to develop basic Servlets: they are an appropriate container for our common Java code that has been factored out of our JSP pages, giving our software development team an area of focus that is as loosely coupled to our JSP pages as possible. Certainly, there will be a need for these same individuals to work with the JSP source pages, but the dependency is reduced, and these pages become the focus of the web-production team instead. Of course, if the same individual fulfills both roles, as is typical on a smaller project, such dependencies are not a major concern.

So, we should try to minimize the Java code that we include within our JSP page, in order to uphold this cleaner separation of developer roles. As we have discussed, some of this Java code is appropriately factored to a mediating Servlet. Code that is common to multiple requests, such as authentication, is a good candidate for a mediating Servlet. Such code is included in one place, the Servlet, instead of potentially being cut and pasted into multiple JSPs.

We will also want to remove much of our business logic and data access code from our JSP page and encapsulate it within JavaBeans, called worker or helper beans. We start to see a pattern of code movement from our JSP into two areas: a Servlet (or JSP) that sits in front of the main JSP, and JavaBeans that sit in back. We refer to this common pattern as 'Factor Forward-Factor Back', as shown in the figure below:

Factor Forward-Factor Back

Rather, the page should communicate our intent by revealing the delegating messages we send to worker beans, instructing them to get state from a model, or to complete some business processing.